Red Iron steel buildings exhibit remarkable strength and resilience, courtesy of their I-beam construction. These traits make them stand tall against diverse weather conditions, coming up as a reliable architectural choice. However, Tubular steel buildings, being lighter with their hollow steel tube structure, miss out on the strength aspect but score high on affordability. This comparison might suggest that picking one over the other is like choosing between an elephant and a bird – mightier strength versus lighter weight. But really, it all comes down to what your project needs and your budget allows. Even so, it’s fair to say that if you’re leaning toward longevity and hardiness, Red Iron Steel might be your go-to option. Now, let’s get into the detailed differences between red iron steel buildings vs tubular steel buildings.

Before we begin, just a quick reminder. We wrote another detailed article last week about metal buildings vs conventional stick frame buildings. We believe it’s important to understand the pros and cons of each building style.

Red iron steel buildings are generally preferred over tubular steel due to their exceptional durability, structural strength for withstanding diverse weather conditions, and the capability for fully customizable designs. Moreover, red iron’s fire resistance and water barrier properties make it a popular choice for structures such as garages, storage facilities, riding arenas, and more.

Red Iron Steel Buildings vs Tubular Steel

Major Differences Between Red Iron and Tubular Steel

The primary distinction between red iron and tubular steel is their construction. Red iron steel buildings are crafted using durable I-beams, which offer exceptional strength and structural integrity. These I-beams are expertly designed to withstand various types of weather conditions, making red iron buildings an ideal choice for projects requiring resilience against harsh environments.

Conversely, tubular steel buildings are constructed using hollow steel tubes, which are typically lighter in weight compared to the robust I-beams used in red iron buildings. These hollow steel tubes provide structural strength but may also necessitate additional support posts along the walls to maintain stability, particularly in larger buildings. It’s essential to weigh the specific project requirements when choosing between these construction materials, as each offers unique benefits and limitations depending on the intended application.

In terms of durability and longevity, red iron steel boasts a reputation for exceptional resistance to wear and tear. The application of a red iron coating on structural steel creates a resilient barrier against water infiltration and provides fire resistance—an invaluable feature in safeguarding the structural integrity of the building.

Moreover, red iron steel buildings can be fully customized to meet diverse project needs, encompassing applications such as garages, storage facilities, riding arenas, auto shops, car wash facilities, RV storage, agricultural buildings, and more. Their adaptability facilitates flexible floor plans with clear-span structures devoid of interior columns, affording ample space for various amenities such as doors, windows, mezzanine decks, and other essential features tailored to specific functional requirements.

On the other hand, while tubular steel buildings offer commendable structural strength, they may require careful consideration due to the need for additional support posts and potential limitations in design flexibility compared to their red iron counterparts. The decision to utilize tubular steel should involve an assessment of the intended use case and design requirements to ensure optimal functionality within budgetary constraints.

Understanding these core differences enables informed decision-making when selecting the most suitable construction material for a specific building project. Whether prioritizing strength, design flexibility, or cost-efficiency, evaluating these aspects can guide stakeholders toward an optimal choice that aligns with their project objectives.

As we continue our exploration into the comparison of construction materials, let’s now venture into unraveling the physical properties that distinguish red iron from tubular steel.

Physical Properties of Red Iron and Tubular Steel

Let’s start with red iron steel. In the realm of construction, red iron steel stands as the heavyweight champion. Fashioned with sturdy I-beams, it boasts exceptional strength, allowing it to withstand the harshest weather conditions without yielding. This structural robustness makes red iron steel buildings a popular choice for an array of uses, from garages to agricultural buildings. The ability to endure harsh elements and maintain structural integrity over time distinguishes red iron steel as a superior building material.

It’s akin to comparing a sturdy castle made of stone to a house made of straw; one can withstand the strongest winds and rains, while the other might not fare well under similar conditions. That’s the caliber of robustness that red iron steel embodies.

On the other hand, tubular steel buildings are fashioned using hollow tubular steel members, making them lighter in weight than structures fabricated from red iron. This lighter weight bears advantages in transportation and assembly. However, it also means that tubular steel buildings are not as strong as those constructed from red iron. The trade-off between strength and weight is a key consideration when deciding between these two options.

The difference in strength can be likened to comparing a heavy-duty pickup truck to a compact car. While both have their specific uses and strengths, the pickup truck offers more durability and resilience when tackling tough terrain or carrying heavy loads.

Understanding these distinct physical properties of red iron and tubular steel sheds light on their respective strengths and weaknesses, enabling informed decision-making based on specific project requirements.

With this understanding in mind, let’s now explore the specific advantages offered by red iron steel buildings.

Advantages of Red Iron Steel Buildings

Red iron steel buildings offer numerous advantages that make them an appealing choice for a variety of construction projects. Let’s break down some of the most notable benefits.

Durability and Weather Resistance

Red iron steel structures are renowned for their exceptional durability and their ability to withstand various weather conditions. This makes them an ideal choice for structures such as garages, storage facilities, car wash facilities, and agricultural buildings. Their robustness ensures that they can endure harsh winds, heavy snow loads, and even seismic activity, providing a secure and long-lasting construction.

The strength of red iron steel provides structural integrity that doesn’t falter in the face of adverse weather. Unlike some other construction materials, red iron steel stands firm against the elements, offering peace of mind to property owners in areas prone to extreme weather events. This enhanced durability is not only a financial benefit but also a safety measure for occupants and stored contents within the building.


One of the standout features of red iron buildings is their full customizability. This allows for complete flexibility in designing the structure, layout, and inclusion of additional features such as doors, windows, mezzanine decks, and various amenities. The ability to fully customize the building’s design means that it can be tailored to suit diverse applications. Whether it’s an expansion of an existing facility or the construction of a brand-new structure, the adaptability of red iron buildings makes them a versatile solution for different project requirements.

This level of flexibility is paramount in catering to the specific needs of businesses and individuals alike. It ensures that each building can be uniquely adapted to fulfill its intended purpose, resulting in a space that maximizes functionality while maintaining an aesthetically pleasing design.

Fire Resistance

The red iron coating on structural steel serves as a formidable barrier against water and provides substantial fire resistance. This pivotal feature enhances the safety of the structure and its contents by significantly reducing the risk of fire-related damage. By incorporating fire-resistant materials into the construction of these buildings, property owners gain an added layer of protection against unforeseen emergencies.

Imagine a commercial storage facility housing valuable equipment and inventory—by choosing a red iron steel building with excellent fire resistance, business owners can safeguard their assets from potential fire hazards. This proactive approach to security speaks volumes about the long-term viability and safety measures implemented within these structures.

The durability, customizability, and fire resistance provided by red iron steel buildings demonstrate how this construction method stands out as a versatile and reliable choice for modern construction needs.

Strength and Durability of Red Iron Steel

When it comes to constructing buildings that must endure heavy loads or harsh environmental conditions, the strength of the materials used is crucial. Red iron steel buildings are esteemed for their robust structural strength, making them a popular choice for various applications where durability is paramount.

The secret behind the exceptional strength of red iron steel lies in its construction using I-beams. These beams provide outstanding load-bearing abilities, ensuring that the building can support significant weight without bending or buckling. This makes red iron steel buildings an ideal choice for applications like manufacturing plants, large storage facilities, agricultural buildings, and distribution centers.

Consider a large manufacturing plant where heavy machinery and equipment are housed. The structural integrity of the building must be such that it can safely accommodate the weight of these machines without any risk of structural failure. In such scenarios, the use of red iron steel provides the necessary peace of mind, knowing that the building’s framework is more than capable of withstanding these substantial loads.

Moreover, in regions prone to extreme weather conditions such as hurricanes or heavy snowfall, the durability of red iron steel becomes even more critical. The ability to withstand intense wind forces, heavy snow loads, and other environmental stressors is essential for ensuring the safety and longevity of any structure. Red iron steel buildings have proven time and again to be resilient in adverse weather conditions, offering a level of protection that is unparalleled.

With its impressive load-bearing capabilities and resilience against environmental challenges, red iron steel stands out as a material that instills confidence in the structural integrity of buildings across various industries.

Moving forward from discussing the remarkable strength of red iron steel buildings, let’s now explore another formidable competitor – tubular steel buildings.

Advantages of Tubular Steel Buildings

One of the key advantages of tubular steel buildings is their lighter weight. In contrast to red iron steel buildings, which are known for their heavy and robust construction, tubular steel buildings are easier to transport and manipulate during construction due to their lighter weight. This characteristic offers distinct advantages in certain project scenarios where weight considerations play a crucial role.

The lightweight nature of tubular steel buildings allows for more flexibility in transportation and installation, particularly in areas with limited access or where heavy machinery might be impractical. This can result in reduced logistical challenges and lower labor costs, contributing to greater overall efficiency in construction projects.

For instance, picture a construction site in a remote area where heavy equipment cannot easily reach. In such cases, the lighter weight of tubular steel components would make them more manageable and practical for assembly, helping to streamline the entire construction process.

In addition to their lighter weight, cost-efficiency is another notable advantage of tubular steel buildings. The simpler manufacturing process and reduced material requirements contribute to making them more cost-effective in certain applications and in the short term.

This balance between strength and affordability makes tubular steel buildings an attractive option for various building projects, especially when budget constraints need to be carefully considered. The cost-effectiveness of tubular steel buildings can also provide opportunities for cost savings without compromising on structural integrity.

This cost-efficiency can be likened to finding a good balance between quality and price when purchasing any product. Tubular steel buildings offer that sweet spot where structural strength meets budget-friendly pricing, allowing for the realization of construction projects within pre-determined financial parameters while still delivering reliable infrastructure.

Armed with a deeper understanding of the benefits offered by tubular steel buildings, it becomes evident that these structures hold significant advantages in terms of weight management and cost-effectiveness, thereby offering a compelling alternative to red iron steel buildings in certain project contexts.

Comparing Red Iron and Tubular Steel Building Designs

When it comes to designing the perfect steel building, understanding the differences between red iron and tubular steel is crucial. Red iron buildings are known for their clear-span structure, meaning no interior columns are needed. This allows for a wide range of possibilities for floor plans and designs, providing incredible flexibility, whether it’s a large open space for a warehouse or a customized layout for a retail establishment.

The absence of interior columns not only provides flexibility but also aids in the efficient utilization of available space. Incorporating various business needs like machinery, storage racks, or office spaces becomes easier without hindrance from structural elements. Additionally, the open space design can create visually appealing and functional interior layouts.

The Restriction with Tubular Steel Buildings

While tubular steel buildings offer some design flexibility, they typically have less structural strength compared to red iron buildings. This can necessitate additional support posts along the walls to ensure stability, impacting overall design options available to builders and architects.

Consider how these variations in design options may influence your project. A red iron building with its clear-span structure offers plenty of room for creativity and tailored functionality. On the other hand, the need for extra support posts in tubular steel buildings may limit your design choices to some extent.

These differences highlight the importance of considering potential impacts on design and layout when selecting the right steel building material. Now, let’s delve further into how these structural differences affect customization and overall construction timelines.

Choosing Between Red Iron and Tubular Steel Buildings

Selecting the right type of steel building is a crucial step that heavily relies on understanding your project’s unique needs and priorities. Whether it’s about constructing a new barn, storage facility, garage, or industrial building, each choice offers its own set of advantages and considerations to weigh. Let’s take a closer look at some key factors that can help you make an informed decision as you navigate the choice between red iron and tubular steel buildings.

Structural Strength

Red iron steel buildings are celebrated for their remarkable strength and durability, making them an ideal choice for projects where robust structural integrity is paramount. These buildings are designed to withstand various types of weather conditions, ensuring the safety and longevity of your structure. On the other hand, tubular steel buildings are generally lighter in weight and may require additional support posts along the walls to compensate for any reduction in structural strength. Therefore, if you prioritize structural reliability, red iron steel might be the more suitable option.

Cost Considerations

When it comes to cost considerations, both red iron and tubular steel buildings have their own economic implications. The cost per square foot for red iron steel typically falls between $8 to $12, making it a cost-efficient option for many projects. Meanwhile, tubular steel buildings usually come with a higher price tag, ranging from $12 to $18 per square foot. Additionally, red iron steel buildings offer faster construction times—25-30% faster than tubular steel constructions—leading to potential savings in labor costs.

Customization Needs

If customization is a top priority for your project, tubular steel buildings provide a broader range of customization options compared to their red iron counterparts. These options can include architectural details, interior finishes, and exterior cladding variations tailored to meet specific aesthetic and functional requirements. However, it’s important to note that red iron steel buildings are also fully customizable and offer ample flexibility in achieving diverse project demands while maintaining their structural strength.

Weather Resistance

Red iron steel buildings are known for their durability and ability to withstand various weather conditions, from heavy snow loads to high winds. The red iron coating on structural steel serves as a protective barrier against water while providing fire resistance—an essential feature for ensuring long-term performance in different climates. In contrast, tubular steel buildings may lack the same level of weather resistance as structures made from red iron due to their lighter weight and construction characteristics.

Expert Guidance

At this juncture, thoroughly evaluating these factors in relation to your specific project needs is vital. It’s essential to seek expert guidance from reputable metal building specialists who can provide valuable insights and recommendations tailored to your unique requirements. By consulting metal building experts at ROI Metal Buildings, you can gain access to high-quality materials and expert support throughout the decision-making process.

Making a decision between red iron and tubular steel buildings requires careful consideration of structural strength, cost implications, customization needs, weather resistance, and expert guidance. With these factors in mind, you can confidently choose the most suitable option for your project needs.

A Detailed Guide On Red Iron Steel Buildings vs Tubular Steel

In conclusion, makeing a decision between red iron and tubular steel buildings requires careful consideration of structural strength, cost implications, customization needs, weather resistance, and expert guidance. With these factors in mind, you can confidently choose the most suitable option for your project needs. Call us directly at (865) 316-9009 to get started! Also, if you like our content and want to stay up to date, follow us on Facebook at!

More posts

Stay on the forefront of industry trends by checking out our latest content